6 Best Hamilton Beach Grill Replacement Parts (November 2026)
The best Hamilton Beach indoor grill replacement parts include the CaptainGrill Grease Tray with Catch Pan-Dyna Glo for adjustable drip tray width, the Croask Replacement Grill Grate for Ninja Foodi for Ninja Foodi FG551 grate replacement, and the Direct Parts DC107 19 1/4 Inch Set for matching a two-grid cooking surface.
On this page (6 sections)
The best Hamilton Beach indoor grill replacement parts must match your grill’s exact model and the original part’s dimensions. The options below are made for other named grills, so use them as a guide to the details you need to verify, not as confirmed Hamilton Beach fits.
A replacement grate, drip tray or heating component can look close and still be incompatible. Check the model number, dimensions, shape and attachment points before ordering; for Hamilton Beach compatibility, consult the grill manual or manufacturer support.
Our picks at a glance
-
1
Best for adjustable drip tray widthCaptainGrill Grease Tray with Catch Pan-Dyna Glo
9.7/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
2
Best for Ninja Foodi FG551 grate replacementCroask Replacement Grill Grate for Ninja Foodi
9.5/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
3
Best for matching a two-grid cooking surfaceDirect Parts DC107 19 1/4 Inch Set
9.4/10 our score
See it on Amazon
- 4
Check itDirect Parts Kit DG101 Replacement for Charbroil
Best for a multi-part burner repair - 5
Check itBBQ-PLUS Grill Replacement Parts for Charbroil Classic
Best for Charbroil Classic burner parts - 6
Check itRuiTEERS Grill Replacement Parts for Cuisinart CGG-306
Best for Cuisinart tabletop grill heat plates
How to choose Hamilton Beach indoor grill replacement parts
Choose a replacement by model number first, then compare the original part’s measurements and shape. That order helps rule out parts that share a general name but differ in fit.
Look for a model label on the grill or in its manual. Record the complete model number, then identify the part name and any part number shown in the manual.
Measure the old component before removing or discarding it, if it is safe to do so. For a grate, check length, width, thickness and the location of handles or supports; for a drip tray, check its usable width, depth and how it slides into place.
What should you check before ordering grill parts?
Check the exact grill model, part dimensions and connection points before buying any replacement. Brand names alone are not enough to establish a fit.
The products in this guide illustrate why careful matching matters: the Croask grate specifies Ninja Foodi FG551, while the RuiTEERS flame tamers name Cuisinart CGG-306 and other models. Neither is identified as a Hamilton Beach component.
A broader indoor grill replacement parts guide can help you compare common part types. For context on how a countertop electric grill heats food, see How Do Indoor Electric Grills Work?.
What kinds of replacement parts wear out?
Cooking grates, trays and burner components each solve a different repair need, so identify the failed part before shopping. A grate supports food, while a tray collects drips and burner shields distribute heat in outdoor grills.
For indoor electric grills, the replacement may be a grill plate, grate, drip tray or another model-specific component. Check the manual for the part name and approved replacement; do not assume an outdoor grill burner kit can work in an indoor appliance.
If smoke or grease is part of the problem, the design of the grill can affect where drips go. Our guide to what smokeless means on an indoor grill explains the term and what to check.
How these grill replacement parts compare
These six options differ in part type, dimensions and stated compatibility, and none confirms a Hamilton Beach fit. We compared their described components and model references, with the highest scores going to options that give clear dimensions or cover a defined repair need.
Our score weighs specs, features and buyer feedback against what you’re shopping for.
| Product | Best for | Width | Depth | Material | Our score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CaptainGrill Grease Tray with Catch Pan-Dyna Glo | adjustable drip tray width | 24 to 30 in adjustable | 15 1/2 in | Grade 430 stainless steel | 9.7 |
| Croask Replacement Grill Grate for Ninja Foodi | Ninja Foodi FG551 grate replacement | 9.5 | |||
| Direct Parts DC107 19 1/4 Inch Set | matching a two-grid cooking surface | Porcelain-coated cast iron | 9.4 | ||
| Direct Parts Kit DG101 Replacement for Charbroil | a multi-part burner repair | 9.1 | |||
| BBQ-PLUS Grill Replacement Parts for Charbroil Classic | Charbroil Classic burner parts | 8.8 | |||
| RuiTEERS Grill Replacement Parts for Cuisinart CGG-306 | Cuisinart tabletop grill heat plates | 8.6 |
CaptainGrill Grease Tray with Catch Pan-Dyna Glo: Best for adjustable drip tray width
- Adjustable width from 24 to 30 in
- 15 1/2 in deep
- Includes catch pan
- Three pieces require assembly
The adjustable width and listed depth make this the easiest of these picks to compare against a large grill drip tray. It is described for several outdoor grill brands, so verify your exact model and measurements.
Pros
- Adjustable width
- Catch pan included
- Dimensions are clearly stated
Cons
- Designed for outdoor grills
- Requires assembly
The CaptainGrill tray is an outdoor grill drip pan, not an indoor Hamilton Beach component. Its adjustable 24 to 30 in width and 15 1/2 in depth give you useful measurements to compare if you are replacing a large tray, but the stated compatibility is for outdoor grill brands such as Dyna Glo and Nexgrill.
It comes in three main pieces that assemble to the selected width, with a catch pan included. The maker describes Grade 430 stainless steel construction and a sloped channel that directs grease toward the drain opening.
For a Hamilton Beach countertop grill, this scale and fit are unlikely to match a small removable tray. Measure your original part and confirm the appliance model before considering any substitute.
Croask Replacement Grill Grate for Ninja Foodi: Best for Ninja Foodi FG551 grate replacement
- Made for Ninja Foodi FG551
- 13.36 x 9.1 x 2.63 in
- Double-handle design
- Dishwasher safe
This grate is a specific fit for the Ninja Foodi FG551, with dimensions to compare against your original. It is the closest option here for an indoor grill cooking surface, though it is not identified as a Hamilton Beach part.
Pros
- Named indoor grill model
- Dimensions provided
- Double handles
Cons
- Only compatibility stated is Ninja Foodi FG551
- Not a Hamilton Beach part
The Croask grate is the closest match here to an indoor grill cooking surface because it names the Ninja Foodi FG551. Its 13.36 x 9.1 in footprint and double-handle design give you specific details to compare with an original grate.
Croask describes a non-stick ceramic-coated surface and says it is dishwasher safe. Those features may matter when comparing replacement cooking plates, but the stated fit is for Ninja Foodi FG551 only.
If you own a Hamilton Beach grill, check its manual for the approved grate part number. A similar size alone does not confirm that the supports, height or electrical safety fit your appliance.
For related Ninja accessories, compare Best Ninja Foodi Grill Accessories and Best Ninja Indoor Grill Replacement Parts. Owners of that specific grill family can also check Ninja AG301 accessories and replacement parts.
Direct Parts DC107 19 1/4 Inch Set: Best for matching a two-grid cooking surface
- Set of 2 grids
- Each grid is 12 3/8 x 19 1/4 in
- Porcelain-coated cast iron
- Several outdoor grill models named
This two-grid set suits buyers whose original cooking surface uses a matching pair of large rectangular grids. Compare both the individual grid size and total layout, and confirm your grill model.
Pros
- Individual and overall dimensions provided
- Set contains 2 grids
- Multiple model families listed
Cons
- For larger outdoor grills
- Cast iron grids can be damaged in transit
The Direct Parts DC107 set contains two porcelain-coated cast iron grids, each measuring 12 3/8 x 19 1/4 in. That size and material are aimed at large outdoor grills and named models from brands including Weber, Nexgrill and Jenn-Air.
Use the individual grid measurements, not only the overall combined width, when comparing a replacement. This set is not identified for Hamilton Beach indoor grills, and cast iron grids can be damaged during transport.
Direct Parts Kit DG101 Replacement for Charbroil: Best for a multi-part burner repair
- 4 stainless steel burners
- 4 porcelain steel heat plates
- 3 stainless steel crossover tubes
- Burners are 15 7/8 x 1 in
The DG101 kit covers burners, heat plates and crossover tubes for a set of named Charbroil models. Its part dimensions and model list are useful checks, but it is not presented for Hamilton Beach grills.
Pros
- Several repair parts in one kit
- Burner dimensions provided
- Named Charbroil models
Cons
- Model-specific fit
- Not an indoor grill kit
The Direct Parts DG101 kit is a multi-part repair set for selected Charbroil outdoor grills. It includes 4 stainless steel burners, 4 porcelain steel heat plates and 3 crossover tubes, with burner dimensions of 15 7/8 x 1 in.
This type of kit is relevant only when replacing those components on a compatible gas grill. Hamilton Beach countertop electric grills use a different design, so do not treat this kit as an indoor appliance repair option.
BBQ-PLUS Grill Replacement Parts for Charbroil Classic: Best for Charbroil Classic burner parts
- 3 heat plates
- 3 burners
- 2 adjustable crossover tubes
- Selected Charbroil Classic models
This repair kit groups heat plates, burners and crossover tubes for selected Charbroil Classic and American Gourmet grills. Match each component’s size and your exact model before considering it.
Pros
- Includes three types of parts
- Crossover tubes adjust in length
- Model numbers are specified
Cons
- For named outdoor grill families
- No Hamilton Beach compatibility stated
The BBQ-PLUS kit covers selected Charbroil Classic and American Gourmet grills, with 3 heat plates, 3 burners and 2 adjustable crossover tubes. Its heat plates measure 13 x 4 in, and the burners are 12.6 in long.
Check the exact model number as well as each part size because the listed Charbroil families include different burner counts. The product is intended for outdoor gas grills and does not identify Hamilton Beach compatibility.
RuiTEERS Grill Replacement Parts for Cuisinart CGG-306: Best for Cuisinart tabletop grill heat plates
- 2 flame tamers
- 13 x 6.18 in
- Stainless steel
- Named Cuisinart CGG-306 compatibility
These stainless steel flame tamers are sized for selected tabletop and two-burner grills, including the Cuisinart CGG-306. Check the original plate’s shape and dimensions because this is not a Hamilton Beach part.
Pros
- Two flame tamers included
- Dimensions provided
- Several named models
Cons
- Not a Hamilton Beach replacement
- Original part shape still needs comparison
The RuiTEERS set contains 2 stainless steel flame tamers measuring 13 x 6.18 in. It names the Cuisinart CGG-306, selected Nexgrill models and Megamaster grills as compatible options.
The dimensions can help you understand what to record when measuring a heat plate, but this is not a Hamilton Beach part. Check the original component’s outline and placement, along with the complete grill model number.
Can a replacement part from another brand fit?
A part from another brand can fit only when its maker confirms your exact grill model or the manufacturer approves the replacement. Dimensions are a useful screening step, but they do not confirm safe electrical or mechanical fit by themselves.
For a Hamilton Beach indoor grill, use the model number to find the manual or contact the manufacturer for the correct part number. If you are comparing cooking appliances instead of repairing one, a basket air fryer buying guide covers a different countertop cooking format.
Which Hamilton Beach replacement part should you choose?
Choose a Hamilton Beach replacement only after confirming the appliance model and matching part number or manufacturer-approved dimensions. The listed products here are examples from other grill families, so none can be recommended as a verified fit.
For a cooking surface, prioritize the exact grate shape and support points; for a collection tray, compare its width and depth. If no compatible replacement is available, ask Hamilton Beach whether the part can be ordered or whether the appliance should be serviced.
Pick a part by model and measurements, then confirm compatibility with Hamilton Beach before ordering. For other indoor grill options, start with the guides to Ninja indoor grill replacement parts and how indoor electric grills work.
Our top 3 picks at a glance
-
1
Best for adjustable drip tray width
CaptainGrill Grease Tray with Catch Pan-Dyna Glo
9.7/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
2
Best for Ninja Foodi FG551 grate replacement
Croask Replacement Grill Grate for Ninja Foodi
9.5/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
3
Best for matching a two-grid cooking surface
Direct Parts DC107 19 1/4 Inch Set
9.4/10 our score
See it on Amazon
Frequently asked questions
How do I find the right Hamilton Beach indoor grill replacement part?
Find the grill’s model number and compare it with the part maker’s compatibility details. Then measure the original component, including its length, width, thickness and any tabs or openings that affect how it sits.
A similar-looking part can still be the wrong fit.
Can I use a replacement grate made for another grill?
Only if the manufacturer confirms compatibility or the dimensions and attachment points match your grill. The Croask grate here is identified for Ninja Foodi FG551, not Hamilton Beach.
Check your manual or contact Hamilton Beach with the model number if compatibility is unclear.
Should I replace a damaged indoor grill part?
Replace a part only with one approved for your grill model. Stop using the grill if a damaged component affects its safe operation, and follow Hamilton Beach’s guidance for replacement and use.
For electric grills, do not improvise with a part that does not seat securely.
Are these parts all for Hamilton Beach grills?
No. These options name Dyna Glo, Ninja Foodi, Charbroil, Cuisinart, Nexgrill and other grill families, but none of the supplied product details names Hamilton Beach compatibility.
Treat them as examples of parts to compare by model and dimensions, not confirmed Hamilton Beach fits.
